Form I-9 compliance is more important than ever in 2025. The current administration is focused on enforcing immigration laws, and it is impacting HR administrators across the country. We’re here to help you stay ahead of the curve— and the audits.
Let’s walk through what’s changed, what ICE is looking for, and how Integrity Data HRP for GP & BC makes it all a whole lot easier.
What’s New with Form I-9 in 2025?
As of January 20, 2025, the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) released a new version of Form I-9. It’s valid through May 31, 2027, and includes a few important updates:
- Revised descriptions for two List B identity documents
- Updated statutory language in the instructions
- A refreshed DHS Privacy Notice that aligns with current regulations
You can still use the August 1, 2023 version for now, but we recommend switching to the new one to stay current. You can grab the latest form directly from https://www.uscis.gov/i-9.
ICE Audits Are Heating Up
We’re seeing a renewed focus on immigration enforcement, and ICE audits are expected to increase this year. If your company receives a Notice of Inspection (NOI), you’ll have just three business days to produce your I-9 records.
Here’s what ICE is looking for:
- Missing or incorrect information on forms
- Incomplete or improperly verified documents
- Unauthorized employment
And the penalties are no joke. Paperwork violations can cost up to $2,861 each, and knowingly employing unauthorized workers can run up to $28,619 per offense. If you’re a federal contractor or in a high-turnover industry, you’re especially on ICE’s radar. California employers—don’t forget that 72-hour notice posting requirement.
Need a refresher on what to expect during an audit? SHRM has a great guide—Read it HERE.
CASE STUDY
This HR Manager for a 5-Doctor Hematology Oncology Medical Practice with 130 employees shares the story of what an ICE audit was like for her.
“When I was working as the HR Manager for a medical practice I went through an I-9 audit on my very first year there. The fines were unimaginable, and it was a huge lesson learned for that practice, and to me because I inherited a huge mess. Not one I-9 was at it should have been, so you can imagine what I went through that year. If we would have had Integrity Data HRP, it would have made my job so much easier and saved me so much time. I spent months cleaning up the mess and reporting to our auditor each week. It was a major headache, and I had to devote many overtime hours just to get everything up to speed, as it should have been and to meet the strict deadlines they gave us. On top of that, the practice had to pay thousands of dollars in fees for each I-9, for existing and terminated employees. It would have been a life saver to have Integrity Data HRP for peace of mind to know you are always staying on top of the current and always changing laws. Having the centralized secure I-9 storage and audit ready reporting that Integrity Data HRP offers would have made this process super simple when we were audited, in fact, that is exactly what they were looking for. Sadly, we were still using printed out paper I-9 forms and had them stored inside personnel files, not fully aware of the change to that law back then and found out the hard way, during the audit. If the practice would have had Integrity Data HRP, it would have saved them a great deal of time, aggravation and money spent on unnecessary fines. Most importantly, having the peace of mind, knowing you are always staying compliant”.
Best Practices to Stay Compliant
Here’s what we recommend to keep your I-9 process clean, compliant, and audit-ready:
✅ Conduct Internal Audits
Set aside time to review your I-9s regularly. Look for missing fields, outdated forms, or expired documents. If you’re not sure what to look for, consider bringing in an immigration attorney or a trained HR professional.
✅ Train Your Team
Make sure your HR staff knows how to complete and verify I-9s correctly. And for objectivity, avoid having the same person complete and audit the forms.
✅ Use E-Verify (If Applicable)
If you’re a federal contractor or in a state where it’s required, E-Verify is essential. It’s also a great way to add an extra layer of compliance. Just make sure your account is active and aligned with the 2025 Form I-9 updates. You can learn more at https://www.e-verify.gov/.
✅ Store I-9s Securely
Keep I-9s separate from personnel files and make sure they’re stored securely—whether that’s digitally or on paper. You’ll need to retain them for three years after hire or one year after termination, whichever is later.
Quick Checklist for 2025
Here’s a quick snapshot to keep handy:
☐ Use the latest Form I-9 (Jan 2025 version)
☐ Complete within 3 business days of hire
☐ Verify original, unexpired documents
☐ Store I-9s securely and separately
☐ Conduct regular internal audits
☐ Train HR staff on I-9 procedures
☐ Monitor E-Verify for mismatches
☐ Prepare for ICE visits with a clear protocol
How Integrity Data HRP Makes It Easier
Here’s the good news: you don’t have to manage all of this manually.
With Integrity Data HRP, we’ve built in the tools you need to stay compliant— without the stress:
- ️ I-9s Linked to Employee Records
We make sure your I-9 documentation is securely stored and tied directly to each employee’s personnel file—so you’re always organized and audit-ready. - Secure Digital Storage
Our system meets DHS retention requirements, with access controls and audit trails to protect your data. - E-Verify Integration
If you use E-Verify, our partnership with National Crime Search can help you connect the dots. Our platform, plus National Crime Search, supports seamless verification and helps you stay in good standing. - Audit-Ready Reporting
If ICE comes knocking, you’ll have everything you need at your fingertips.
Want to see how it works? Check out our article on linking workers’ I-9 to E-Verify in Integrity Data HRP.
Final Thoughts
We know the idea of an ICE audit can be panic inducing—but you’re not in this alone. At Integrity Data, we’re here to help you stay ahead of the curve, protect your organization, and make your job just a little bit easier.
LEGAL DISCLAIMER: Integrity Data’s publications and presentations are designed to make employers aware of US Government reporting requirements, best practices for compliance with those requirements, and the consequences of noncompliance.
This material is intended to provide accurate information as of the date posted. It is provided with the understanding that neither Integrity Data, nor the authors and presenters, are rendering legal or accounting advice.
With respect to your organization’s decision making for legal compliance, review the information presented with legal counsel specializing in employment law.
Integrity Data HRP – Your Complete HRIS for Dynamics Including Payroll for BC
Integrity Data HRP is your complete HR, Time Management, and Payroll platform from within Dynamics GP and D365 BC. Everything works together effortlessly so you can focus on what really matters, your people.
- Escape the piles of paper and keep everything in one digital employee file.
- From Applicant to Retirement, you can manage Recruitment & Onboarding, Benefit Elections, Performance Reviews, Certifications & Licenses, Reports, Payroll, Time & Attendance, and much more, all in one solution.
- Employee Self-Service Portal is included for both Business Central and GP.
- Full-Service Tax Filing and ACA Reporting Services available as well.
Reach out today and our no-pressure solution experts will answer your questions to see if we are a good fit for your organization.
Integrity Data has been serving the Dynamics community since 1996. Our passion is to help HR and payroll professionals own their time so they can focus on helping their people. As always, your people are our priority.
Leave A Comment